-->
Showing posts with label Theodore Herzl. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theodore Herzl. Show all posts

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Herzl's vision vs Israel's reality

Theodore Herzl is considered the founder of Zionism as laid out in his book Der Judenstaat (1895).

Today, President Obama on a visit to Israel has laid a wreath at the grave of Herzl, paying him honor in doing so. But the State of Israel is quite different from what Herzl had in mind. A comment on the site, Mondoweiss by Palestinian Ramzi Jaber, puts this in a listing as follows...

Obama must keep the following 12 facts in mind: 
1- Palestinians are the gererous party who are willing to share our land with Israel
2- Herzl dreamed up Zionism to solve a non-Palestinian problem: Jews not being welcome in Europe
3- Zionism imposed a state over land that did not belong to Jews
4- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, the region is not better off because of Israel
5- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, Israel is not a secular democracy
6- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, Israel is not the only democracy in the Middle East.
7- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, Israel is NOT the vanguard of a westernized Middle East (but a throwback to 19th century Europe - CB)
8- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, Israel is not the solution to the Jewish problem
9- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, Israel has created Palestinian homelessness
10- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, emerging popular Middle Eastern governments are not Israel’s allies
11- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, Israel is no longer the oppressed but rather the only superpower (plus nukes) in the ME
12- Contrary to what Herzl dreamed up, Israel never moved beyond 1800s mentality