German author Gunter Grass has released a poem he calls What Must Be Said.
Here is my response to it...
Our psychology, while developed to protect the individual, is very dangerous. At root is the thought that one’s own thinking is objective.
The individual easily assumes that his own reasoning is both logical and based on a hard reality. One also jumps to conclusions about the thinking of others based on suspicion. All of this swims within the mindset created by the psychological environment of the times, in which history plays a large part.
The frightening thing about Israel’s leadership is the mindset of victimization, of “never again”. This paranoia that gives rise to epic self-righteousness sees aggression and the stockpiling of weapon upon weapon as normal, it sees the unilateral pre-emptive strike as prudent. It sees “get him before he gets you” as common sense. With this mindset, what the world sees as peace will never come because no action on the part of the other except abject subservience will ever be acceptable.
Netanyahu and friends are incapable of seeing themselves in the other and do not have any conception that humiliation is unappealing to everyone; Jew, Arab and Iranian alike.
Outside Israel, the horror of the holocaust and feelings of guilt have created a different mindset, one that says “we must never criticize Jews, because they are a special case in history with which we are complicit” This is strongest in Germany for obvious reasons and it is made manifest by submarines and financial payments.
Put these two complimentary mindsets together and you have a license for Israel to commit all manner of mayhem – the perpetrators feeling no qualms about whatever they do, and the Western observers trying to assuage their consciences by saying little or nothing about the mayhem.
This is why Grass so perfectly titles his effort “what must be said”. He wants to shatter this rigid psychological crystal that binds both the Israelis and the West and makes Israeli initiated tragedy inevitable.
Israel is a not a result of the action of a group of dedicated Jewish fighters in Palestine. That was necessary but not sufficient for the creation. Far from a miracle of God as some would have it, Israel is the result of the complementary mindsets described above acting in concert. As with so many things, what seemed to many like a good idea at the time is now playing out into a disaster of human rights and potential world war.
Grass’ work will likely have little effect on his generation or the one after. It is only the youth who are born free of the mindset (before it is inculcated) that have the fresh eyes that will make it possible to stop feeding Israel with the weaponry that makes it the beast it was inevitable it would come to be.
Thursday, April 12, 2012
regarding Gunter Grass' poem
Tuesday, April 10, 2012
targeting UNRWA
The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), which I have mentioned before, could hardly be a more benevolent organization. It has been providing for the Palestinian refugees from just after the establishment of Israel to the present time. The 58 refugee camps it maintains are a reminder of the fact that millions of people are still prevented by Israel from returning to the towns from which they were evicted.
Obviously, these camps are facts on the ground which Israel would love to see eliminated and it should be no surprise that the Jewish state has done all it can over the years to oppose funding for UNRWA.
I just received a notice from UNRWA that it will not be able to run the summer games for Palestinian youth that it has conducted for the past six years due to a shortage of funds.
In the United States, U.S. Representative Illeana Ros-Lehtinen is continually acting for Israel in calling for the elimination of funding for anything having to do with the Palestinians, UNRWA in particular. Israel, however is the beneficiary of billions of dollars annually agreed to for ten year periods and then gets additional gifts on top of it.
This is testimony to the control of U.S. foreign policy in Israel/Palestine by the Israel lobby.
You might consider donating to UNRWA on your own, as I do. It's the least an American citizen can do to counteract the capture of the Congress.
Saturday, April 7, 2012
Peace, Propaganda and the Promised Land
"We don't see the suffering that the Palestinians are undergoing through the occupation. We don't really understand how bad the occupation is for them. No empathy. The sympathy. No sight of women unable to reach a hospital to give birth and...their babies dying at the checkpoint because they can't get through. If you don't see that your heart doesn't skip a beat and say - something is wrong with the occupation."
Peace, Propaganda and the Promised Land is an 80 minute video that, though it goes no further than the years of Ariel Sharon as Israeli Prime Minister, it hits all the topics that remain true today. The techniques of Israel's PR are covered fully along with the failure of U.S. journalists to do their job of reporting the whole story. Unfortunately, it all remains true today.
This is the video that Rick Steves viewed and afterward commented that he felt he had been duped by Israel.
The program is available for sale but you can watch it all if you are willing to put up with the words FOR PREVIEW ONLY faintly displayed throughout.
Peace, Propaganda and the Promised Land is an 80 minute video that, though it goes no further than the years of Ariel Sharon as Israeli Prime Minister, it hits all the topics that remain true today. The techniques of Israel's PR are covered fully along with the failure of U.S. journalists to do their job of reporting the whole story. Unfortunately, it all remains true today.
This is the video that Rick Steves viewed and afterward commented that he felt he had been duped by Israel.
The program is available for sale but you can watch it all if you are willing to put up with the words FOR PREVIEW ONLY faintly displayed throughout.
Friday, April 6, 2012
Monday, April 2, 2012
how do ceasefires end?
Nancy Kanwisher has written an article at the Huffington Post that documents how lulls in conflict between Israel and the Palestinians end. It contains this remarkable chart...
To the left is the percentage of conflicts that end after the number of days specified at the bottom. The bars are black for Israel, gray for Palestinian attacks and white for both on the same day. As can easily be seen, for all pause durations shown, Israel is always the leader in resuming attacks and is the only party that resumes attacks after the longer pause durations (10 days or more). The full article is well worth reading.
Tuesday, March 20, 2012
what was Khader Adnan trying for?
After almost 70 days of his hunger strike, Palestinian Khader Adnan's term in Israeli prison was reduced. As I have mentioned previously, Adnan was in prison on "administrative detention" that allows the Israeli military to put anyone in prison for months and then extend that term on the say of an Israeli military officer, all the while with no charges filed.
Yes, it's an outrage that the United States should not support, but of course we do and you will never heard a word about it in Congress.
But Adnan was not starving himself to end the practice of administrative detention in itself. He was wasting away to protest the entire colonial occupation of Israel. The Electronic Intifada provides an English translation of an excellent article explaining the reasoning behind Adnan's hunger strike and the hunger strikes of current Palestinian prisoners that are following his example.
Yes, it's an outrage that the United States should not support, but of course we do and you will never heard a word about it in Congress.
But Adnan was not starving himself to end the practice of administrative detention in itself. He was wasting away to protest the entire colonial occupation of Israel. The Electronic Intifada provides an English translation of an excellent article explaining the reasoning behind Adnan's hunger strike and the hunger strikes of current Palestinian prisoners that are following his example.
Monday, March 19, 2012
protesting at Batsheva Dance performance
On Saturday night I participated in a demonstration at the Auditorium Theater in Chicago where the Israeli Batsheva Dance company was performing. This video shows the occasion. The sign I carried said "Take the ART out of apARTheid"
It's important to demonstrate at every event that attempts to portray Israel in a positive light, ignoring the terrible injustice that has been present there since the creation of the state in 1948 - and that continues today.
It's important to demonstrate at every event that attempts to portray Israel in a positive light, ignoring the terrible injustice that has been present there since the creation of the state in 1948 - and that continues today.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
